Skip to Content
Skip to Navigation

Jose Antonio Vargas

in
June, 2011

How did you decide to write about your own history as an undocumented immigrant?
It was time. This is a story I've been too afraid to tell, certainly too afraid to write about. Lawyers advised me not to write it, especially not the way I wanted to write it. But my mind and heart were set. Mine is just one of countless untold and unexamined stories of undocumented immigrants across America: of all ages, from varying ethnic backgrounds, interwoven in every fabric of our society. I've been a working journalist for more than 12 years, and the most useful kind of story to me is one that illuminates a greater truth -- a shared experience. Thankfully, I worked with editors (some from the Washington Post, others from the New York Times Magazine) who made the essay better and fuller. To write about oneself is always challenging, and I was fortunate -- I am fortunate -- for being ready and able to write the truth.

You wrote the piece without knowing what was going to happen. What is your biggest fear?
From the legal point of view, I am ready for anything and everything that could happen. But more than that, I was afraid that the story may not resonate, that it would not have impact beyond the here and now, beyond myself.

What impact has the piece had so far?
People are talking about immigration in a different way - at least that's been the biggest impact judging by the tweets, Facebook messages and emails we are getting at DefineAmerican.com. Our small team at Define American -- all close friends of mine -- set out to change and elevate the conversation around immigration. We're succeeding, and we're just getting started.

Have you had any response from immigration authorities?
No.

How did you come to write the piece for the New York Times, specifically?
The essay was originally intended for the Washington Post, where I was a reporter for a little more than five years. I owe the Post a great deal of my professional identity. I love that newspaper -- always have, always will -- and I felt it was the right place for the essay to run. But after weeks of rigorous editing, after the piece was ready to go, the Post's top leaders decided it was not right for them. Thankfully, Peter Baker, a friend and a former colleague at the Post who's now at the New York Times, helped me get the essay into the New York Times Magazine. Editors at the Magazine quickly grabbed the story. I am grateful to them.

Some media critics have argued that you shouldn't have covered immigration or immigrant-related stories while your status was still undisclosed because you had a bias. Do you feel that someone who is out-of-status has any more of a bias than someone who is in-status?
Reporters are just like other human beings. Our identities and backgrounds inform how we see the world and serve as a lens in which we see other people. Having said that, it's less about who is doing the reporting and writing and more about how a story is reported and written. Regardless of one's background, a news story should be judged by how insightful, fair and accurate it is. By those standards, my work speaks for itself. And it will continue to speak for itself.

Tell me about the Define American project? What is it? What do you hope to accomplish?
Define American is about changing and elevating the way we talk about immigration in this country. It's a new way of looking at an old issue. Illegal immigration is not just about the undocumented immigrants in our country. It's also about the American citizens, from pastors to principals, who are members of what I've been calling the 21st century Underground Railroad. These Americans have stepped up where the government has failed. If anything else, Define American can reframe how we talk and examine this issue. In a country that's been built and replenished by immigrants, we have a very narrow and misinformed way of dealing with immigration.

What are your predictions for the DREAM Act?
The DREAM Act is almost 10 years old. The failure of the DREAM Act -- and other immigration reform-related legislation -- to pass through Congress is a testament to how broken our politics are when it comes to this very important issue. We have failed, and failure is unacceptable.

Backstory Archive

Yes
June, 2013
Frey, PBS Need To Know team win the June Sidney Award for his coverage of migrant deaths along the U.S.-Mexico border

Juan Carlos Frey and PBS Need to Know team (producer Brian Epstein, correspondent John Larson and editor Judith Starr Wolff) win the June Sidney Award for exposing the rising death rate among undocumented migrants attempting to cross the U.S.-Mexico border. 

Yes
May, 2013
Manik, Greenhouse, and Yardley win the May Sidney Award for their coverage of the Rana Plaza factory collapse in Bangladesh

Julfikar Ali Manik, Steven Greenhouse, and Jim Yardley of the New York Times won the May Sidney Award for their extensive coverage of the Rana Plaza factory collapse in Bangladesh. The seven-story factory complex crumbled on April 24, burying over 1100 people. Most of the victims were garment workers who died sewing clothes for Western companies like Walmart and Benetton. 

Yes
April, 2013
Joe and Harry Gantz Win April Sidney for “American Winter,” an HBO documentary about middle-class families falling into poverty

Joe and Harry Gantz won the April Sidney Award for American Winter, a documentary that follows eight Portland, Oregon-area families struggling to survive the winter of 2011/2012 in the grip of the Great Recession.

Yes
February, 2013
Arizona Republic Wins February Sidney for Exposing a Faulty HPV Test Linked to False-Negative Results and Undetected Cancers

Bob Ortega won the February Sidney Award for sounding the alarm about a faulty test for HPV, the virus that causes most cervical cancer. Each year, about 12,000 women are diagnosed with cervical cancer and about 4,000 die of the disease. 

Yes
January, 2013
Bloomberg News Wins January Sidney for A Tale of Two McDonald's

Leslie Patton of Bloomberg News won the January Sidney Award for her profile of McDonald’s as seen by a fry cook and the CEO of the company. 

Yes
December, 2012
Josh Eidelson of The Nation Wins December Sidney for Coverage of Historic Walmart Strike

Josh Eidelson of The Nation won the December Sidney Award for his coverage of the historic Black Friday strike at Walmart and the ongoing strike wave moving through Walmart’s supply chain.

Yes
November, 2012
Jina Moore of the Christian Science Monitor Wins November Sidney for Inquiry Into American Poverty

Jina Moore, regular contributor to the Christian Science Monitor, won the November Sidney Award for Below The Line: Poverty In America, a portrait of poverty as it is measured by official statistics and lived by real people.

No
October, 2012

Sasha Chavkin, Anna Maria Barry-Jester and Ronnie Greene of the Center for Public Integrity won the October Sidney Award for “Mystery in the Fields,” an international investigation into a mystery kidney disease killing young farm workers in India, Sri Lanka, and Central America.

No
September, 2012

Erich Schwartzel and Julia Rendleman of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette won the September Sidney Award for “Fouled Waters,” a 3-month investigation into a mysterious blight on the water supply of The Woodlands, a small Pennsylvania town surrounded by natural gas wells.

No
August, 2012

A 13-journalist team led by International Consortium of Investigative Journalists Director Gerard Ryle and ICIJ reporter Kate Willson won the August Sidney Award for “Skin and Bone,” a sweeping investigation of the largely unregulated global trade in human tissues.

No
July, 2012

Monica Potts of the American Prospect won the July Sidney Award for her portrait of poverty and enterprise in Appalachia.